locknload wrote:But really who wants to live with 9 months of winter? Other than the access to fort mac, this has to be one of the least desirable places to live.
locknload wrote:The place in question was Edmonton not Alberta , we all know all about Alberta.
locknload wrote:Other than jobs which the good paying, plentiful ones are in Fort Mac , which u should know .

locknload wrote:Why are the houses cheaper....bottom line is demand. That's why all the places u mentioned are more expensive, look at the population of all those cities!They must have something going for them!
locknload wrote:But lets live in winter bound Edmonton
thadeus wrote:locknload wrote:The place in question was Edmonton not Alberta , we all know all about Alberta.
Last time I checked, Edmonton was in Alberta.locknload wrote:Other than jobs which the good paying, plentiful ones are in Fort Mac , which u should know .
I know exactly what I'm talking about. It's you that needs to check the facts. No one is debating the high paying jobs in Fort McMurray but to say that there are no other high paying jobs in Edmonton is completely untrue.
http://www.payscale.com/research/CA/Cit ... ourly_Rate
http://www.payscale.com/research/CA/Cit ... ourly_Rate
Yes, wages in Fort McMurray are, for the most part, higher than in Edmonton but once you get into a trade, the wages are quite similar.
And here's a map of Alberta's "Industrial Heartland."
Let's count the projects...
1-Synenco
2-Petro-Canada
3-Access
4-Enbridge
5-BA Energy
6-Shell
7-Stat Oil
8-Total
Hardly makes it look like the only plentiful, good paying jobs are in Fort McMurray. And if you're not familiar with Fort Saskatchewan, it's about 20-25 minutes outside of Edmonton. There'll be LOTS of Edmontonians working at those construction sites/plants.locknload wrote:Why are the houses cheaper....bottom line is demand. That's why all the places u mentioned are more expensive, look at the population of all those cities!They must have something going for them!
This statement really illustrates your ignorance as to what's going on in Edmonton and the world of real estate in general. You think my list of cities is full of places with properties that are more expensive than in Edmonton? Let's compare.
The Realtors Association of Edmonton's stats from August of this year say that the average home in Edmonton is priced at approximately $370,000 (http://www.ereb.com/pdf/MonthlyStats.pdf). I hit MLS and Comfree and picked two houses at random in that price range. I chose southwest Edmonton as that's by and large considered the most desirable section of the city in which to live. First, Comfree...
http://edmonton.comfree.ca/display.html?code=24285
3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, 1,400sqft, attached two car garage, even comes with central a/c. Aside from the purple bedroom, it's not a bad looking house for $373,000.
http://www.mls.ca/PropertyDetails.aspx? ... ID=7492180
On MLS, $375,000 gets you a next-to-new two-story, 2,200sqft house with a gas fireplace and a detached two car garage. Again, pretty nice.
Let's see what $375,000 buys us in Vegas...
http://www.realtor.com/search/listingde ... 137#Detail
5 bedroom, 3 bathroom, 4,100sqft, swimming pool, 3 car garage. Hmm, that seems like a step up from Edmonton but, using your logic, prices should be higher in Vegas because of the warm weather and larger population. That's probably an anomaly. Let's check Phoenix...
http://www.realtor.com/search/listingde ... =46#Detail
Not quite as grand in as in Vegas as it's only 3,300sqft but, in my opinion, the pool is much nicer.
http://www.realtor.com/search/listingde ... t=3#Detail
Not quite as many details on this home in San Diego put still pretty nice.
http://www.realtor.com/search/listingde ... =56#Detail
In Miami, we spent a little more but, wow, it's pretty impressive looking.
The only place from my list that's dollar-for-dollar more expensive is Vancouver but it's affordability is WAY worse than Edmonton's and while the lower mainland's winter's are famously mild, they've got a long way to go before they catch up with anything else on the list. And yes, all those city's have a larger population than Edmonton.
Your theory of nicer weather, bigger city = more demand, higher prices seems to have a few holes in it. You may want to work the bugs out.locknload wrote:But lets live in winter bound Edmonton
I agree with you that, given the opportunity, the majority of people would prefer to live someplace with a tropical climate and no snow, but the reality is that most people aren't in that position. Most people's checklists look like this:
1-Can I get a good job and make a good wage where I'm going?
2-Will the overall quality of life be good for me and my family?
3-Will I be able to afford to buy my own home?
Weather is WAY down on the list.
It's clear to me that non-biased information from StatsCan, RBC, CMHC and whoever put this study together are no match for your dislike of cold temperatures.
First thing Monday morning, you should get on the phone and call the people listed above and inform them that they wasted their time earning degrees and compiling this in depth research. Tell them you can't imagine shoveling snow and would never move to Edmonton simply for that reason, regardless of the economic advantages for you and your family. I'm sure they'll print a retraction and change their mind once you inform then it actually gets COLD in Edmonton...
locknload wrote:But really who wants to live with 9 months of winter? Other than the access to fort mac, this has to be one of the least desirable places to live.
locknload wrote:thats why all the money hungry guys go to F. mac. Still it's too far north livin in Calgary. Ya I'm here for the less money, still couldn't pay me enough to move up there!![]()
DAB wrote:locknload wrote:thats why all the money hungry guys go to F. mac. Still it's too far north livin in Calgary. Ya I'm here for the less money, still couldn't pay me enough to move up there!![]()
my friend works in F. mcmurray, says u can get paid there in the 6 digit range. way more than anywhere else. key is to work ur ass off for sevearl years...save enough to come back to a 'normal' city and then take it easy. downside, from the gruesome weather & work, he look about 10 years more than his real age.
locknload wrote:DAB wrote:locknload wrote:thats why all the money hungry guys go to F. mac. Still it's too far north livin in Calgary. Ya I'm here for the less money, still couldn't pay me enough to move up there!![]()
my friend works in F. mcmurray, says u can get paid there in the 6 digit range. way more than anywhere else. key is to work ur ass off for sevearl years...save enough to come back to a 'normal' city and then take it easy. downside, from the gruesome weather & work, he look about 10 years more than his real age.
The real problem there is the cost of living is sooo high, ie a small 3 bed hse will rent for 3500 - 4500 a month top floor only, if you don't take it someone else will. Groceries, another problem, you just take it for granted that they won't run out of the staples, but they regularly do. Then try to staff those businesses, massive lineups to get thru the tills . There "were" 2 tim hortons in town, one closed because they couldn't staff it.
Sound like fun yet? divorce rate of 70% It's a great place to be FROM.
People don't have a clue what to expect when they talk about going there to find work.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest